Pro Life vs. Pro Choice – Stan Hupfeld

Posted in: Club Newsletter, Featured
Stan Hupfeld

Stan Hupfeld

Recently I was reflecting on the relationship between abortion policy and the Democratic Party. The divide between pro-life and pro-choice is very simple. The pro-life position is that life occurs at the moment of conception. The pro-choice opinion is that life does not begin until the instant the fetus exits the birth canal. I believe the former position is the truth, but I would not doubt the sincerity of anyone holding the opposing view.

Recently I asked an obstetrician friend who occasionally performed termination of pregnancy procedures on what basis he made his decision. As I understood his answer it was that in the early stages of development a life was not present. For him life did not begin until this mass of tissue transformed into an entity that could live (albeit with significant medical intervention) outside the womb. In other words, for him life began at the point of viability.

My concern is that both sides of this argument cast the other as either morally repugnant or simply stupid. I am afraid the pro-choice adherents have painted themselves into a corner over late term abortion. Since their philosophy is that life does not occur until the moment the fetus exits the womb they are left with endorsing some fairly gruesome medical procedures. In order to justify their position they have to assume that, as late in the pregnancy as mere seconds before the fetus enters the world, they are solely the property of the mother’s body. This leaves them in a seemingly untenable position that the mother can assent to and the physician can perform any manner of macabre procedure including crushing the fetus’s head to ensure a child is not born alive.

What I think has happened is the concern that if pro-choice believers give an inch then the pro-life people will ultimately win the argument and move back the time when an abortion can be performed, even past the point of viability.

It’s unfortunate the two sides in this intense argument cannot discuss the subject without criticizing their opponents’ morality or intelligence.

3 Comments for : Pro Life vs. Pro Choice – Stan Hupfeld
    • John Frost
    • October 13, 2016

    Brave comment. I, too, believe in the continuity of life back to once potion. If a baby can be “owned” then it might be sold as body parts, another repugnant thought. Birth control, adoption, and even abstinence are acceptable alternatives.

    The Supreme Court has shaped the law in a twisted fashion by creating a right not encompassed by the Constitution. Consider this when voting this November.

    • Larry Stone
    • October 15, 2016

    The myth that all pro-choice advocates believe they can abort babies without consequence until seconds before birth should be retired. Rather, pro-choice advocates believe that the life and wealthfare of the mother play a critical role in any pregnancy. Placing everyone with an opinion into one of two groups, each with an absolutist agenda, must diminish the likelihood of reasonable and productive discussion of the issues.

    Originalist argue that SCOTUS created a right out of thin air with Roe, but the court began developing a “privacy zone” foundation in cases during the 1920s. Roe determined that abortion fit under the privacy guarantees in the fourteenth amendment and reasserted the government’s right to involvement in order to safeguard the health of the mother and the state’s developing interest in the fetus resulting in limits on when abortions would be allowed.

  1. If you believe there is a God in heaven, creator of all life, and that ‘He orders the steps of those who love Him’….then you believe that everything has a purpose….one that we so often don’t understand. There maybe those who want to inject themselves into the process by deciding against the baby based on factors they deem legitimate…..but when we step in and say “We know better” aren’t we elevating ourselves to the position of God ?

Comments are closed.

Change this in Theme Options
Change this in Theme Options